AskIt Logo
  • New to BJJ?Starter Guide
  • The RulesDos & Don’ts
  • White Belt Problems
  • Starting BJJ
  • Learning BJJ Faster
  • BJJ for Self Defense
  • BJJ Belts & Promotion
  • BJJ vs Other Martial Arts
Home » BJJ Belts & Promotion » Should a lower belt student ever be able to tap out a higher belt in BJJ?
1

Should a lower belt student ever be able to tap out a higher belt in BJJ?

- John Q. Whitebelt

Posted by John Q. Whitebelt in BJJ Belts & Promotion | 1 comment

Community Answers

  1. 68
    9-8-14
    Marshal D. Carper says:

    Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu ranks are at the same time incredibly meaningful and entirely meaningless.

    Bear with me.

    Belts and stripes are a powerful tool for measuring progress and for creating a sense of community within a gym. When an instructor awards a belt, students naturally find that experience very meaningful. The belt represents at once the student’s growth and the instructor’s recognition of that growth. At the same time, advancing in rank can also signify a larger role within the gym as upper belts are often informally expected to be mentors. These sorts of things give a belt meaning.

    From gym to gym though, ranks are a lot fuzzier. The skill level of a purple belt in one gym can be dramatically different from the skill level of a purple belt from another gym. Perhaps one gym holds students back longer for competition purposes. Perhaps one student trains full-time and the other trains a few times a week because of work and family obligations. Maybe one is younger and athletic and the other is older but has been training longer.

    Can you start to see how even at the same rank two jiu-jiteiros of the same rank could not be precisely equal in competitive terms? In this way, an athletic blue belt that trains six days a week and competes regularly could be a handful for a brown belt that only trains three times a week as a hobby.

    If a lower belt taps an upper belt, it’s not the end of the world. It happens, for many different reasons. Again, focus on training and learning, not on who wins and who loses.

    Log in to Reply
    +135

    Was this answer helpful?

    LikeDislike

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

IMPORTANT NOTE: By submitting an answer, you give permission for it to be published in future editions of the White Belt Problems book.

Ask a BJJ Question

Buy the Book on Amazon

Categories

  • BJJ Belts & Promotion
  • BJJ Books & DVDs
  • BJJ Competition
  • BJJ Etiquette
  • BJJ Fitness & Diet
  • BJJ for Fitness
  • BJJ for Kids
  • BJJ for Self Defense
  • BJJ Gis & Gear
  • BJJ History
  • BJJ Injuries
  • BJJ Lifestyle & Culture
  • BJJ Techniques
  • BJJ vs Other Martial Arts
  • Finding a BJJ School
  • Health & Hygiene
  • Learning BJJ Faster
  • Starting BJJ
  • White Belt Problems

Recent Questions

  • Youth to adult transition
  • private lessons when your a newbie worth it or not?
  • Is it good practice for a beginner to be at open mats?
  • Is it ok to wear shirts and gear of other people/academies that im a fan of?
  • Is an open level gym bad?

Recent Answers

  • dogs_bolx on Is it good practice for a beginner to be at open mats?
  • LittleAussieGrappler on Does Gi color matter?
  • LittleAussieGrappler on What makes a martial art effective?
  • LittleAussieGrappler on private lessons when your a newbie worth it or not?
  • LittleAussieGrappler on Does BJJ prepare you for self defense?

Categories

  • BJJ Belts & Promotion
  • BJJ Books & DVDs
  • BJJ Competition
  • BJJ Etiquette
  • BJJ Fitness & Diet
  • BJJ for Fitness
  • BJJ for Kids
  • BJJ for Self Defense
  • BJJ Gis & Gear
  • BJJ History
  • BJJ Injuries
  • BJJ Lifestyle & Culture
  • BJJ Techniques
  • BJJ vs Other Martial Arts
  • Finding a BJJ School
  • Health & Hygiene
  • Learning BJJ Faster
  • Starting BJJ
  • White Belt Problems
  • Home
  • About
  • Ask a Question
  • Beginner’s Guide to Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu
  • Contact
  • Dashboard
  • Edit Post
  • Rules
  • Sitemap
  • Your Profile
  • BJJ Belts & Promotion
  • BJJ Books & DVDs
  • BJJ Competition
  • BJJ Etiquette
  • BJJ Fitness & Diet
  • BJJ for Fitness
  • BJJ for Kids
  • BJJ for Self Defense
  • BJJ Gis & Gear
  • BJJ History
  • BJJ Injuries
  • BJJ Lifestyle & Culture
  • BJJ Techniques
  • BJJ vs Other Martial Arts
  • Finding a BJJ School
  • Health & Hygiene
  • Learning BJJ Faster
  • Starting BJJ
  • White Belt Problems